final-form vs react-hook-form
Side-by-side comparison of final-form and react-hook-form
- Weekly Downloads
- 539.0K
- Stars
- 3.0K
- Gzip Size
- 6.2 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 2d ago
- Open Issues
- 119
- Forks
- 221
- Unpacked Size
- 382.4 kB
- Dependencies
- 2
- Weekly Downloads
- 19.2M
- Stars
- 44.5K
- Gzip Size
- 15.3 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 13h ago
- Open Issues
- 121
- Forks
- 2.4K
- Unpacked Size
- 1.3 MB
- Dependencies
- 2
Download Trends
Verdict
final-form is designed for developers seeking a framework-agnostic form state management solution that prioritizes high performance and subscription-based state tracking. It serves applications that require lightweight form handling without being tied to a specific framework, making it suitable for a variety of environments.
In contrast, react-hook-form is tailored for React developers who want a performant and extensible forms library integrated with React Hooks. Given its extensive weekly downloads and large community, it's recommended for teams already familiar with React and looking to leverage the library's capabilities for complex form management.
When choosing between them, consider the project size and team expertise. final-form may fit better in small to medium applications without a specific framework dependency, while react-hook-form excels in React-centric environments with larger teams who benefit from its extensibility and active community support.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | final-form | react-hook-form |
|---|---|---|
| Licensing | MIT License, promoting open-source use. | MIT License, allowing flexibility in usage. |
| Use Cases | Ideal for framework-agnostic projects requiring custom state management. | ✓Best suited for complex forms in React applications. |
| Bundle Size | ✓Minimal at 6.2 kB gzipped, ensuring quick load times. | Larger at 15.3 kB gzipped, though still reasonable for form management. |
| Open Issues | 119 open issues indicating ongoing development and user feedback. | 121 open issues, similar in activity levels. |
| Performance | High performance with a focus on subscription-based state management. | Performant with React Hooks, optimized for interactive forms. |
| Extensibility | Subscription-based architecture allows direct state management. | ✓Highly extensible with a strong ecosystem around React. |
| Unpacked Size | ✓Compact at 382.4 kB, suitable for small projects. | Larger at 1.3 MB, may be a consideration for project scales. |
| Learning Curve | ✓Easy to pick up for developers familiar with form state management concepts. | Moderate learning curve, especially for newcomers to React Hooks. |
| Weekly Downloads | 539.2K downloads per week. | ✓19.1M downloads per week, indicating higher adoption. |
| Community Support | Moderate community with 3K stars on GitHub. | ✓Strong community support boasting 44.5K stars on GitHub. |
| Maintenance Activity | Updated recently, indicates active maintenance. | Updated recently, ensuring relevance in the ecosystem. |
| Framework Compatibility | ✓Framework agnostic, usable with any front-end framework. | Tightly coupled with React, uses React Hooks. |