formik vs react-hook-form
Side-by-side comparison of formik and react-hook-form
- Weekly Downloads
- 3.5M
- Stars
- 34.4K
- Gzip Size
- 17.9 kB
- License
- Apache-2.0
- Last Updated
- 3mo ago
- Open Issues
- 836
- Forks
- 2.8K
- Unpacked Size
- 585.0 kB
- Dependencies
- 8
- Weekly Downloads
- 19.2M
- Stars
- 44.5K
- Gzip Size
- 15.3 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 13h ago
- Open Issues
- 121
- Forks
- 2.4K
- Unpacked Size
- 1.3 MB
- Dependencies
- 2
Download Trends
Verdict
Formik excels in scenarios where forms are complex, providing a structured approach and extensive support for form validation. With a large community and adoption, it is well-suited for teams experienced in React who prefer a solution that integrates tightly with traditional component-driven architecture.
React-hook-form offers a lightweight and performant solution that integrates seamlessly with React Hooks. It tends to be a better fit for projects that require a more flexible, straightforward approach to forms, particularly those that prioritize performance and developer experience.
While migration from Formik to React-hook-form may require rethinking how forms are structured, the smaller bundle size and increased flexibility of React-hook-form may be worth the shift for new projects or simpler forms. However, teams familiar with Formik will find its structured approach beneficial for complex scenarios, despite its larger size and slightly higher learning curve.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | formik | react-hook-form |
|---|---|---|
| License | Apache-2.0 license allows for wide usage and customization. | ✓MIT license is more permissive and simpler. |
| Version | Older version, less frequently updated. | ✓More recent version with the latest features and enhancements. |
| Description | Focuses on building complex forms with in-depth validation support. | Designed for flexible and performant forms using React Hooks. |
| Open Issues | 836 open issues indicate potential challenges and ongoing development. | ✓121 open issues suggest a more stable and active development process. |
| GitHub Forks | ✓2.8K forks indicate a healthy level of experimentation. | 2.4K forks are fewer, but still suggest a solid user base. |
| GitHub Stars | 34.4K stars show significant interest and engagement. | ✓44.5K stars suggest higher popularity and perceived utility. |
| Unpacked Size | ✓Smaller size at 585.0 kB is beneficial for optimizing bundle sizes. | Larger size of 1.3 MB may impact initial load times. |
| Learning Curve | Steeper learning curve due to complexity and structure. | ✓More straightforward for developers familiar with React Hooks. |
| Weekly Downloads | 3.5M downloads indicate solid but lesser popularity. | ✓19.1M downloads reflect strong community adoption and usage. |
| Community Support | Strong but slightly less active community compared to react-hook-form. | ✓Highly active community, which can aid in quick issue resolution. |
| Intended Use Case | Best for complex forms needing detailed validation. | ✓Ideal for simple to moderately complex forms with high performance. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | Bundle size of 17.9 kB is manageable for performance. | ✓Slightly smaller bundle size at 15.3 kB offers a performance edge. |