@tanstack/react-form vs formik
Side-by-side comparison of @tanstack/react-form and formik
- Weekly Downloads
- 858.0K
- Stars
- 6.3K
- Gzip Size
- 17.6 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 3d ago
- Open Issues
- 169
- Forks
- 586
- Unpacked Size
- 297.5 kB
- Dependencies
- 9
- Weekly Downloads
- 3.5M
- Stars
- 34.4K
- Gzip Size
- 17.9 kB
- License
- Apache-2.0
- Last Updated
- 3mo ago
- Open Issues
- 836
- Forks
- 2.8K
- Unpacked Size
- 585.0 kB
- Dependencies
- 8
Download Trends
Verdict
Both @tanstack/react-form and formik cater well to form management in React applications, but they target slightly different audiences. @tanstack/react-form emphasizes type safety and advanced features, appealing more to teams familiar with TypeScript and looking for robust solutions. In contrast, formik is established and friendly for developers who prefer a higher-order component approach, making it accessible for a broader range of users.
When to choose @tanstack/react-form over formik would depend on project needs—if your application heavily utilizes TypeScript and you seek intricate form validations, @tanstack/react-form is the better choice. Conversely, for simpler forms or when working with teams that have varying levels of experience, formik provides a more intuitive interface. Consider your team’s familiarity with hooks and TypeScript when making this decision.
Migration from formik to @tanstack/react-form may require considerable adaptations due to differences in API and type management. Notably, while @tanstack/react-form offers a more modern approach, formik's larger community and existing resources can be beneficial for ongoing support and faster onboarding for new developers.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | @tanstack/react-form | formik |
|---|---|---|
| License | MIT, allowing for broad flexibility. | Apache-2.0, also permissive but with a different structure. |
| Version | ✓1.28.0, indicating a recent development cycle. | 2.4.9, slightly older but stable. |
| Categories | Specifically in the Form category, showcasing its targeted use. | Also focused on the Form category, highlighting niche expertise. |
| Description | Powerful, type-safe forms for React. | ✓Build forms in React, without the tears |
| Open Issues | ✓169, suggesting areas for improvement. | 836, indicating more active discussions or issues. |
| GitHub Forks | 586, suggesting moderate experimentation. | ✓2.8K, indicating high levels of community involvement. |
| GitHub Stars | 6.3K, reflecting a good level of interest. | ✓34.4K, demonstrating significant popularity. |
| Unpacked Size | ✓297.5 kB, which is relatively compact. | 585.0 kB, larger than @tanstack/react-form. |
| Topics Covered | ✓Diverse topics including TypeScript, offering flexibility. | Focused mostly on forms, indicating a specialized approach. |
| Weekly Downloads | 860.3K, indicating a growing user base. | ✓3.5M, showing strong adoption and community support. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | ✓17.6 kB, minimal for performance. | 17.9 kB, slightly larger but still efficient. |