jotai vs redux
Side-by-side comparison of jotai and redux
- Weekly Downloads
- 2.8M
- Stars
- 21.0K
- Gzip Size
- 6.8 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 17h ago
- Open Issues
- 6
- Forks
- 703
- Unpacked Size
- 507.8 kB
- Dependencies
- 2
- Weekly Downloads
- 21.6M
- Stars
- 61.5K
- Gzip Size
- 1.4 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 4d ago
- Open Issues
- 44
- Forks
- 15.2K
- Unpacked Size
- 289.8 kB
- Dependencies
- 1
Download Trends
Verdict
jotai offers a primitive and flexible approach to state management specifically tailored for React applications, making it ideal for projects that favor atomic state management. In contrast, redux serves as a more traditional predictable state container suitable for JavaScript apps and can be applied to a broader range of frameworks beyond React.
For developers working on smaller to medium-scale applications, jotai may be easier to integrate and provide more flexibility with its atomic paradigm. Conversely, teams experienced with redux’s principles and patterns may find it beneficial for larger applications that require a stable and comprehensive state management system.
While jotai has fewer dependencies and is lighter in size, redux, with its robust community support and extensive resources, may present a steeper learning curve for newcomers. Teams should assess their project needs and existing familiarity with these paradigms when deciding which option to implement.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | jotai | redux |
|---|---|---|
| License | MIT license provides flexible usage rights. | MIT license equally provides flexible usage rights. |
| Open Issues | ✓5 open issues suggest effective maintenance and community support. | 43 open issues indicate more challenges but also a high volume of user feedback. |
| GitHub Forks | 703 forks demonstrate some community engagement for custom modifications. | ✓15.2K forks signify a robust community for extensibility. |
| GitHub Stars | 21.0K stars suggest a solid level of community interest. | ✓61.4K stars indicate a significantly larger community backing. |
| Last Updated | Last updated on the same date as redux, ensuring both are fairly recent. | Last updated on the same date as jotai, ensuring current support. |
| Unpacked Size | 507.8 kB is relatively larger, which may matter for performance-sensitive projects. | ✓289.8 kB represents a more compact solution. |
| Learning Curve | ✓Has a lower learning curve for new projects, especially within React. | Steeper learning curve, but more comprehensive for large-scale applications. |
| Target Audience | Best suited for React-focused projects looking for simplicity. | ✓Ideal for broader JavaScript applications with complex state management needs. |
| Weekly Downloads | 2.7M weekly downloads indicate growing usage in niche projects. | ✓21.6M weekly downloads show redux's dominance and established user base. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | 6.8 kB gzip size is larger and may impact load times in web projects. | ✓1.4 kB gzip size is minimal, enhancing performance. |
| State Management Paradigm | Atomic state management allows for granular reactivity. | Centralized state management provides predictable state updates. |