@heroicons/react vs @tabler/icons-react
Side-by-side comparison of @heroicons/react and @tabler/icons-react
- Weekly Downloads
- 2.4M
- Stars
- 23.3K
- Gzip Size
- 224 B
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 4mo ago
- Open Issues
- 1
- Forks
- 1.3K
- Unpacked Size
- 3.7 MB
- Dependencies
- 1
- Weekly Downloads
- 1.2M
- Stars
- 20.2K
- Gzip Size
- —
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 3h ago
- Open Issues
- 148
- Forks
- 1.1K
- Unpacked Size
- 46.3 MB
- Dependencies
- —
Download Trends
Verdict
@heroicons/react is ideal for projects that need a consistent, minimalistic design aligned with Tailwind CSS, making it particularly suited for developers working within the Tailwind ecosystem. In contrast, @tabler/icons-react offers a broader selection of high-quality SVG icons, catering more towards developers seeking flexibility in web applications and varied design aesthetics.
For smaller projects or those already utilizing Tailwind CSS, @heroicons/react would be a beneficial choice due to its compact bundle size and high weekly downloads, suggesting active community support. Conversely, for larger applications or teams that require a diverse icon set, @tabler/icons-react might be preferable, despite its larger unpacked size and number of open issues.
When considering trade-offs, it's worth noting that @tabler/icons-react has a significantly larger unpacked size, which could impact load performance in smaller applications. However, its extensive library can be advantageous for applications needing a variety of icons without aesthetic constraints.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | @heroicons/react | @tabler/icons-react |
|---|---|---|
| License | MIT licensed, ensuring open use | Also MIT licensed, similar open use |
| Version | Version 2.2.0, recently updated | ✓More recent at version 3.36.1 |
| Flexibility | Less flexible, focused on Tailwind CSS styling | ✓Offers a broader range of SVG icons suitable for various designs |
| Open Issues | ✓Only 1 open issue, suggesting good maintenance | 148 open issues, hinting at potential concerns |
| GitHub Forks | ✓1.3K forks, indicating developer interest in customization | 1.1K forks, also showing some interest |
| GitHub Stars | ✓23.3K stars suggesting strong community approval | 20.1K stars, also indicative of community interest |
| Unpacked Size | ✓Compact at 3.7 MB, easier for quick loads | Substantial at 46.3 MB, could impact performance |
| Weekly Downloads | ✓2.4 million downloads indicate strong popularity | Lower at 1.2 million but still significant |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | ✓Minimal at 224 B, enhancing performance | Not specified, potentially larger given unpacked size |
| Community Activity | ✓High weekly downloads and low open issues indicate active support | Lower downloads and many issues may suggest less active community focus |