i18next vs next-intl
Side-by-side comparison of i18next and next-intl
- Weekly Downloads
- 12.6M
- Stars
- 8.5K
- Gzip Size
- 13.9 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 3d ago
- Open Issues
- 11
- Forks
- 683
- Unpacked Size
- 568.7 kB
- Dependencies
- 1
- Weekly Downloads
- 1.5M
- Stars
- 4.1K
- Gzip Size
- 16.5 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 2d ago
- Open Issues
- 46
- Forks
- 345
- Unpacked Size
- 390.2 kB
- Dependencies
- 10
Download Trends
Verdict
i18next is a comprehensive internationalization framework that caters to a broad range of applications, supported by a large community evident in its significant number of downloads and GitHub stars. It excels in flexibility and is suitable for diverse environments, making it ideal for teams needing robust internationalization capabilities across various platforms.
In contrast, next-intl targets internationalization specifically for Next.js applications, offering seamless integration for developers working within the React ecosystem. It may be the preferred choice for small to medium projects where Next.js' unique features can be fully utilized, especially for teams familiar with React that want to implement i18n quickly.
When considering migration, teams already using i18next may need to evaluate the benefits of transitioning to next-intl versus leveraging their existing setup, as the latter offers a more tailored solution for Next.js applications but may introduce additional complexity for more extensive projects reliant on broader i18n features.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | i18next | next-intl |
|---|---|---|
| Bundle Size | ✓Lightweight bundle size of 13.9 kB, good for performance. | Slightly larger bundle size at 16.5 kB, impacting load times. |
| Ease of Use | Flexibility may lead to a steeper learning curve for new users. | ✓Simpler, tailored for Next.js makes it easier for React developers. |
| Flexibility | ✓Highly flexible, allowing integration across various environments. | Less flexible as it is closely aligned with Next.js structures. |
| Open Issues | ✓Few open issues (11) suggest active maintenance and responsiveness. | More open issues (46) indicate potential unresolved concerns. |
| GitHub Stars | ✓8.5K stars reflect a large and engaged user base. | 4.1K stars demonstrate interest but less community engagement. |
| Last Updated | Updated recently, ensuring it stays relevant and up-to-date. | Also up-to-date, but only marginally more recent than i18next. |
| Unpacked Size | Larger at 568.7 kB, reflecting its extensive feature set. | ✓Smaller at 390.2 kB, suitable for lightweight applications. |
| Weekly Downloads | ✓High usage with 12.6M downloads indicates strong community support. | 1.5M downloads is respectable but significantly lower than i18next. |
| Community Support | ✓Strong community evident in forks and stars, indicating high adoption. | A smaller community may mean less support and fewer resources available. |
| Overall Positioning | ✓Comprehensive framework suitable for various platforms and use cases. | Focused solution specifically for Next.js applications. |
| Use Case Suitability | Ideal for diverse applications needing extensive i18n support. | ✓Best for Next.js projects requiring straightforward integration. |