@lingui/core vs next-intl
Side-by-side comparison of @lingui/core and next-intl
- Weekly Downloads
- 933.2K
- Stars
- 5.6K
- Gzip Size
- 2.3 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 9h ago
- Open Issues
- 65
- Forks
- 430
- Unpacked Size
- 55.4 kB
- Dependencies
- 4
- Weekly Downloads
- 1.5M
- Stars
- 4.1K
- Gzip Size
- 16.5 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 2d ago
- Open Issues
- 46
- Forks
- 345
- Unpacked Size
- 390.2 kB
- Dependencies
- 10
Download Trends
Verdict
@lingui/core provides comprehensive internationalization tools aimed at JavaScript developers, particularly those within the React ecosystem. Its focus on message formatting and localization makes it suitable for projects that require a robust solution for diverse languages and messages.
In contrast, next-intl is specifically designed for Next.js users, offering an optimized experience for applications built on this framework. It is a better choice for projects that are already leveraging Next.js and need straightforward i18n capabilities without excessive overhead.
Consider @lingui/core for larger projects requiring complex localization, while next-intl is ideal for smaller Next.js applications where simplicity and efficiency in implementation are priorities.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | @lingui/core | next-intl |
|---|---|---|
| Open Issues | 60 open issues indicate ongoing challenges or active development. | ✓46 open issues show relatively better maintenance for next-intl. |
| GitHub Forks | ✓430 forks suggest active engagement and experimentation with @lingui/core. | 345 forks show decent involvement with next-intl, but slightly less active. |
| GitHub Stars | ✓5.6K stars show good community interest in @lingui/core. | 4.1K stars, though fewer, still indicate solid community backing for next-intl. |
| Last Updated | Updated recently, showing that @lingui/core is being actively maintained. | Also recently updated, ensuring that next-intl is current. |
| Unpacked Size | ✓55.4 kB, relatively lightweight and suitable for larger projects. | 390.2 kB, considerably larger, which may affect performance in small projects. |
| Learning Curve | Comprehensive features may present a steeper learning curve for newcomers. | ✓Simpler integration for Next.js users, leading to a gentler learning experience. |
| Community Topics | ✓Broad range of topics, making it versatile for various projects. | Focuses on specific Next.js needs, useful for targeted i18n features. |
| Weekly Downloads | 938.5K indicates solid usage, but not as high as next-intl. | ✓1.5M downloads reflect strong adoption across projects. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | ✓2.3 kB is minimal, contributing to faster load times. | 16.5 kB is larger, potentially impacting initial load in client-heavy apps. |
| Overall Positioning | Comprehensive i18n tools for the React ecosystem. | ✓Optimized for internationalization within Next.js. |
| Practical Recommendation | Ideal for large applications needing complex i18n mechanics. | ✓Best suited for quick implementation in Next.js projects. |