notistack vs react-toastify
Side-by-side comparison of notistack and react-toastify
- Weekly Downloads
- 1.3M
- Stars
- 4.1K
- Gzip Size
- 13.0 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 1y ago
- Open Issues
- 66
- Forks
- 296
- Unpacked Size
- 459.3 kB
- Dependencies
- 5
- Weekly Downloads
- 3.2M
- Stars
- 13.4K
- Gzip Size
- 12.8 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 5mo ago
- Open Issues
- 100
- Forks
- 739
- Unpacked Size
- 535.7 kB
- Dependencies
- 3
Download Trends
Verdict
notistack excels in providing highly customizable notification snackbars that can be stacked, making it suitable for applications requiring extensive control over notification appearance and behavior. It is a solid choice for developers familiar with Material Design and using Material-UI, specifically targeting React-Redux applications.
On the other hand, react-toastify offers a more straightforward implementation for notifications, catering to developers who need quick and simple solutions without the extensive customization options. It may be preferable for smaller projects or teams that prioritize ease of use and quick integration over deep customization.
Migration from one package to the other might require code alterations due to their differing implementations and APIs, but both packages exhibit good performance metrics and flexibility in various use cases, making the choice largely dependent on project requirements and developer familiarity.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | notistack | react-toastify |
|---|---|---|
| Version | 3.0.2, offering reliability but with a slightly older version compared to react-toastify | ✓11.0.5, indicating more recent updates and features |
| Ease of Use | Requires deeper understanding for full potential utilization | ✓Designed for quick setup and use, making it very user-friendly |
| Open Issues | ✓66 open issues, which may imply a more actively managed codebase | 100 open issues, which could suggest that react-toastify has a larger base of user-reported improvements needed |
| GitHub Forks | 296 forks, suggesting moderate interest for modifications | ✓740 forks, showing a higher likelihood of community contributions and customizations |
| GitHub Stars | 4.1K stars, showing a good level of community appreciation | ✓13.4K stars, indicating a significantly larger community endorsement |
| Last Updated | Updated on 2025-01-18, indicating ongoing maintenance | ✓Updated on 2025-08-25, reflecting more frequent updates |
| Unpacked Size | ✓459.3 kB, relatively compact for a feature-rich library | 535.7 kB, slightly larger, which may impact load times in small projects |
| Target Use Case | Best for complex applications needing rich notifications | Great for simpler applications requiring straightforward notifications |
| Weekly Downloads | 1.3 million downloads, demonstrating solid community usage | ✓3.2 million downloads, indicating higher popularity and adoption |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | 13.0 kB, offering a leaner bundle for production | ✓12.8 kB, marginally smaller, making it slightly more efficient in production |
| Documentation Quality | Well-documented with examples, particularly for Material-UI | ✓Highly accessible documentation aimed at rapid onboarding |
| Customization Flexibility | ✓Offers extensive customization specifically targeted at Material Design | Simpler customizability focused on ease of use |