notistack vs sonner
Side-by-side comparison of notistack and sonner
- Weekly Downloads
- 1.3M
- Stars
- 4.1K
- Gzip Size
- 13.0 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 1y ago
- Open Issues
- 66
- Forks
- 296
- Unpacked Size
- 459.3 kB
- Dependencies
- 5
- Weekly Downloads
- 12.6M
- Stars
- 11.9K
- Gzip Size
- 13.9 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 1mo ago
- Open Issues
- 60
- Forks
- 406
- Unpacked Size
- 165.8 kB
- Dependencies
- 3
Download Trends
Verdict
notistack is a highly customizable option for developers looking to implement notification snackbars that can be stacked, making it ideal for complex UIs and applications requiring multiple notifications. It is well-suited for teams that are experienced in Material-UI and prefer leveraging Google Material design principles, offering flexibility in styling and configuration.
In contrast, sonner presents a more opinionated approach to toast notifications, targeting developers who prefer simplicity and ease of use. It may be better suited for projects that prioritize quick implementation and do not require extensive customization, especially for teams that are newer to React or wish to avoid a steep learning curve.
While both packages have their strengths, notistack’s larger user base and established community might offer more support and resources. However, teams might consider the slightly larger bundle size of sonner when evaluating their options, especially if bundle size is a critical factor in their application architecture.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | notistack | sonner |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of Use | May have a steeper learning curve for beginners due to customization. | ✓Designed for quick integration with less complexity. |
| Open Issues | 66 open issues, suggesting some ongoing improvements or challenges. | 60 open issues indicate a similar level of active development. |
| Project Fit | Ideal for complex applications needing advanced UI notification management. | Best for simpler projects requiring straightforward toast notifications. |
| GitHub Forks | 296 forks demonstrate some community engagement. | ✓406 forks indicate a slightly more engaged community around sonner. |
| GitHub Stars | 4.1K stars reflects a respectable level of community interest. | ✓11.9K stars highlights sonner's popularity and approval from developers. |
| Last Updated | Updated on 2025-01-18, relatively recent. | ✓Last updated on 2025-12-23, indicating more active maintenance. |
| Unpacked Size | 459.3 kB, larger size may affect performance. | ✓165.8 kB is comparatively minimal, beneficial for load times. |
| Weekly Downloads | 1.3M downloads indicates a solid user base. | ✓12.5M downloads suggest widespread usage and popularity among developers. |
| Community Support | Active community with a focus on Material-UI. | ✓Larger community possibly providing more resources and examples. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | ✓13.0 kB is fairly efficient for a component library. | 13.9 kB is slightly larger than notistack. |
| Customization Options | ✓Highly customizable for designers leveraging Material-UI. | Opinionated design with limited customization options. |