@ark-ui/react vs @headlessui/react
Side-by-side comparison of @ark-ui/react and @headlessui/react
- Weekly Downloads
- 408.2K
- Stars
- 5.0K
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 6h ago
- Open Issues
- 5
- Forks
- 185
- Unpacked Size
- 2.8 MB
- Weekly Downloads
- 4.1M
- Stars
- 28.4K
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 1mo ago
- Open Issues
- 78
- Forks
- 1.2K
- Unpacked Size
- 1.0 MB
Download Trends
Verdict
@ark-ui/react positions itself as a versatile collection of unstyled and accessible UI components that leverage state machines to enhance interaction in React applications. This package serves developers looking for a flexible design system that can integrate with various frameworks beyond React, such as Solid, Svelte, and Vue.
In contrast, @headlessui/react is tailored specifically for those using Tailwind CSS, emphasizing the integration of accessible, unstyled components that work well within that ecosystem. If your team is experienced with Tailwind and prioritizes maximum customizability with accessibility, @headlessui/react may be the better option, especially for larger projects or those heavily reliant on Tailwind’s utility-first approach.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | @ark-ui/react | @headlessui/react |
|---|---|---|
| License | Utilizes the MIT license, promoting open use. | Also under MIT license, ensuring broad permissions. |
| Version | Latest version is 5.31.0, indicating ongoing updates. | Has version 2.2.9, also in active development. |
| Open Issues | ✓Only 4 open issues, indicating good stability and quick maintenance. | 78 open issues might suggest more ongoing challenges. |
| GitHub Forks | 185 forks suggest moderate interest in modifications. | ✓1.2K forks indicate significant development and customization from users. |
| GitHub Stars | 5.0K stars reflect a solid user base. | ✓28.4K stars demonstrate strong community approval. |
| Unpacked Size | At 2.8 MB, it's larger, potentially leading to longer load times. | ✓Smaller at 1.0 MB, contributing to faster performance. |
| Learning Curve | ✓Could require familiarization with state machines for optimal use. | Tailwind users will find it intuitive, while newcomers may face a steeper learning curve. |
| Target Audience | Best suited for developers seeking a general UI component library. | Ideal for those who already use Tailwind CSS in their projects. |
| Weekly Downloads | With 401.0K weekly downloads, indicating moderate popularity. | ✓More popular with 4.1M weekly downloads, suggesting wider adoption. |
| Component Accessibility | Strong emphasis on accessibility with headless components. | Also provides fully accessible components but with a Tailwind focus. |
| Integration Flexibility | ✓Compatible with multiple frameworks like React, Vue, and Svelte. | Primarily designed for React with a focus on Tailwind CSS integration. |