@reduxjs/toolkit vs recoil
Side-by-side comparison of @reduxjs/toolkit and recoil
- Weekly Downloads
- 10.9M
- Stars
- 11.2K
- Gzip Size
- 15.0 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 13h ago
- Open Issues
- 255
- Forks
- 1.3K
- Unpacked Size
- 7.0 MB
- Dependencies
- 5
- Weekly Downloads
- 470.5K
- Stars
- 19.5K
- Gzip Size
- 29.5 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 1y ago
- Open Issues
- 323
- Forks
- 1.2K
- Unpacked Size
- 2.2 MB
- Dependencies
- 3
Download Trends
Verdict
@reduxjs/toolkit is a comprehensive state management solution designed specifically for Redux applications. Its opinionated structure and extensive features make it ideal for larger projects or teams familiar with Redux concepts, providing a full-featured toolset with a strong community backing.
On the other hand, recoil offers a more flexible state management approach that integrates seamlessly with React. It may be a better choice for smaller projects or teams seeking simplicity and agility, especially those wanting to manage state in a React-native manner without the overhead of Redux.
Consider @reduxjs/toolkit for applications where a robust Redux solution aligns with the project architecture. Recoil, however, might present a gentler learning curve for developers looking for a straightforward state management solution without needing to adopt Redux's overall concept.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | @reduxjs/toolkit | recoil |
|---|---|---|
| License | MIT license ensures permissive usage. | MIT license allows flexibility and freedom. |
| Version | ✓Latest version is 2.11.2, indicating active development. | Latest version is 0.7.7, showing slower progress. |
| Description | A comprehensive toolkit for efficient Redux development. | A state management library tailored for React applications. |
| Open Issues | ✓254 open issues may indicate ongoing challenges. | 323 open issues point to possible concerns in Recoil's development. |
| GitHub Forks | 1.3K forks suggesting a good level of experimentation. | 1.2K forks indicating decent community engagement. |
| GitHub Stars | Well-received with 11.2K stars, showcasing community approval. | ✓More recognized with 19.5K stars, indicating strong interest. |
| Best Use Case | Optimal for comprehensive state management tasks in Redux applications. | Suitable for React-centric projects requiring flexible state solutions. |
| Unpacked Size | A larger footprint at 7.0MB, which includes extensive features. | ✓A smaller size of 2.2MB, indicating a lightweight library. |
| Learning Curve | Steeper learning curve due to its depth and complexity. | ✓Easier entry for developers familiar with React. |
| Weekly Downloads | ✓Significant popularity with 10.9M downloads. | Lower popularity with 471.1K downloads. |
| Community Support | ✓Strong community with countless resources and documentation available. | Growing community support but not as established as Redux. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | ✓Minimal at 15.0kB, enhancing performance in production. | Slightly larger at 29.5kB, potentially impacting load times. |