@reduxjs/toolkit vs valtio
Side-by-side comparison of @reduxjs/toolkit and valtio
- Weekly Downloads
- 10.9M
- Stars
- 11.2K
- Gzip Size
- 15.0 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 13h ago
- Open Issues
- 255
- Forks
- 1.3K
- Unpacked Size
- 7.0 MB
- Dependencies
- 5
- Weekly Downloads
- 1.1M
- Stars
- 10.1K
- Gzip Size
- 5.8 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 13d ago
- Open Issues
- 2
- Forks
- 283
- Unpacked Size
- 101.1 kB
- Dependencies
- 3
Download Trends
Verdict
@reduxjs/toolkit is designed for developers looking for a comprehensive solution to build and manage large-scale applications using Redux. It offers a complete toolset that simplifies state management with a clear opinionated structure, making it ideal for teams familiar with Redux or needing to implement robust state management across complex applications.
In contrast, valtio is aimed at those seeking a simpler, more flexible approach to state management with a focus on proxies. It fits well for smaller to medium-sized applications or projects where developers prefer a lightweight alternative that reduces boilerplate and enhances reactivity without the need for extensive Redux knowledge.
When considering migration, teams transitioning from Redux to valtio might find it beneficial due to valtio's simpler API and proxy-based state handling. However, adopting @reduxjs/toolkit is advisable if you are planning a long-term project that requires comprehensive state management features, while valtio serves well for quicker development cycles where less overhead is desired.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | @reduxjs/toolkit | valtio |
|---|---|---|
| Open Issues | 254 open issues suggest active development and ongoing improvements. | ✓Only 2 open issues imply a more stable package but less community engagement. |
| GitHub Stars | ✓11.2K stars show widespread appreciation and usage among developers. | 10.1K stars indicate a solid but smaller following. |
| Unpacked Size | At 7.0 MB, it's larger reflecting its extensive features. | ✓101.1 kB makes it lightweight, ideal for fast-loading applications. |
| Learning Curve | Requires familiarity with Redux patterns, may be challenging for new users. | ✓Easier to learn with a more intuitive API, especially for smaller teams. |
| Team Experience | Recommended for teams with Redux experience. | Good for teams looking for a quick and less complex solution. |
| Weekly Downloads | ✓Far higher at 10.9M, indicating strong community usage. | 1.1M downloads reflect a smaller but growing user base. |
| Community Support | ✓Strong community support due to extensive documentation and popularity. | Growing community, but less established documentation. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | 15.0 kB is moderate, balancing features with download size. | ✓5.8 kB indicates minimal overhead, beneficial for performance. |
| Overall Positioning | ✓Comprehensive toolset for Redux development suited for large-scale applications. | Lightweight and flexible state management solution for smaller projects. |
| Use Case Suitability | Best suited for complex applications needing a structured approach. | ✓Ideal for simpler projects or quick prototypes. |
| Evolution and Updates | ✓Regular updates keep it in sync with best practices in Redux. | Frequent updates, showing active maintenance and quick adoption of features. |