recoil vs valtio
Side-by-side comparison of recoil and valtio
- Weekly Downloads
- 470.5K
- Stars
- 19.5K
- Gzip Size
- 29.5 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 1y ago
- Open Issues
- 323
- Forks
- 1.2K
- Unpacked Size
- 2.2 MB
- Dependencies
- 3
- Weekly Downloads
- 1.1M
- Stars
- 10.1K
- Gzip Size
- 5.8 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 13d ago
- Open Issues
- 2
- Forks
- 283
- Unpacked Size
- 101.1 kB
- Dependencies
- 3
Download Trends
Verdict
recoil is a solid choice for React applications that require complex state management, particularly when dealing with derived states and asynchronous data. It serves teams that prefer a more structured and powerful state management solution within the React ecosystem. Conversely, valtio excels in simplicity and a more straightforward API, making it ideal for both React and Vanilla applications, especially for small to medium-sized projects where quick setup and performance are priorities.
When choosing between recoil and valtio, consider the complexity of your state management needs and your team's expertise. For larger projects or those requiring intricate state interactions, recoil offers more features and a comprehensive approach. In contrast, valtio shines for simpler applications or for teams looking to leverage proxies with minimal setup overhead.
While both libraries share the MIT license and are well-maintained, recoil has a larger community presence with higher GitHub metrics but comes with a bigger bundle size and more open issues. Valtio boasts a smaller footprint and fewer open issues, making it potentially easier to integrate and maintain in the long run.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | recoil | valtio |
|---|---|---|
| License | MIT license provides standard rights and conditions. | MIT license offers the same benefits with no distinction. |
| Version | 0.7.7 is an early version with fewer features. | ✓2.3.0 reflects a more mature package with evolving capabilities. |
| Use Cases | Best for complex React apps needing deep state management. | ✓Ideal for simpler or smaller applications requiring proxy state. |
| Categories | Focused solely on State Management in React. | ✓Covers both State Management in React and Vanilla. |
| Open Issues | 323 open issues might indicate ongoing challenges. | ✓2 open issues reflect a stable and well-maintained package. |
| GitHub Forks | ✓1.2K forks show substantial community experimentation. | 284 forks suggest lesser experimentation. |
| GitHub Stars | ✓19.5K stars signify a strong community interest. | 10.1K stars indicate a moderately popular package. |
| Last Updated | Last updated on 2025-01-01 shows potential staleness. | ✓Last updated on 2026-01-26 indicates ongoing development. |
| Unpacked Size | 2.2 MB is relatively large for a state management library. | ✓101.1 kB offers a compact option for developers. |
| Learning Curve | May have a steeper learning curve due to complexity. | ✓Designed to be simple and straightforward for quick onboarding. |
| Weekly Downloads | 471.1K downloads indicate a strong user base. | ✓1.1M downloads suggest wider adoption and popularity. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | 29.5 kB is larger, impacting load times. | ✓5.8 kB is minimal, ensuring swift performance. |