recoil vs redux
Side-by-side comparison of recoil and redux
- Weekly Downloads
- 470.5K
- Stars
- 19.5K
- Gzip Size
- 29.5 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 1y ago
- Open Issues
- 323
- Forks
- 1.2K
- Unpacked Size
- 2.2 MB
- Dependencies
- 3
- Weekly Downloads
- 21.6M
- Stars
- 61.5K
- Gzip Size
- 1.4 kB
- License
- MIT
- Last Updated
- 4d ago
- Open Issues
- 44
- Forks
- 15.2K
- Unpacked Size
- 289.8 kB
- Dependencies
- 1
Download Trends
Verdict
Recoil is designed specifically for React applications, providing a flexible state management solution that integrates seamlessly with React's component model. It is ideal for projects that prioritize React's capabilities and require a modern, more reactive approach to state management. Conversely, Redux serves as a predictable state container applicable across various JavaScript frameworks, making it versatile for diverse applications beyond just React.
When deciding between the two, consider your project's complexity and team familiarity with state management concepts. Recoil may be more suitable for smaller projects or teams experienced with React, offering a simpler API for managing global state. In contrast, Redux is preferable for larger applications requiring a robust architecture, particularly when managing significant state changes or integrating with other libraries and middleware.
Migrating from one to the other may require a substantial rewrite of state management logic, particularly for teams transitioning from Redux's more formal structure to Recoil's simpler hooks-based API. Given the increased popularity of Redux, expect a larger community for support, resources, and existing solutions, while Recoil's relatively newer approach may lead to learning opportunities but less available guidance.
Detailed Comparison
| Criteria | recoil | redux |
|---|---|---|
| License | MIT License, allowing for commercial use and modification. | MIT License, providing similar freedoms. |
| Version | Latest version is 0.7.7, indicating ongoing development. | ✓Latest version is 5.0.1, a stable version for long-term use. |
| Description | Tailored for React state management with a modern API. | A flexible state container for various JavaScript applications. |
| Open Issues | 323 open issues, suggesting areas requiring attention. | ✓43 open issues, indicating better maintenance or fewer outstanding problems. |
| GitHub Forks | 1.2K forks, indicating moderate interest in customization. | ✓15.2K forks, suggesting extensive developer experimentation and extensions. |
| GitHub Stars | 19.5K stars, reflecting a solid community response. | ✓61.4K stars, demonstrating significant popularity and trust. |
| Unpacked Size | 2.2 MB unpacked size, which may be slightly heavier for some applications. | ✓289.8 kB unpacked size, lighter and may result in better performance. |
| Weekly Downloads | 471.1K weekly downloads, showing a healthy adoption in specific circles. | ✓21.6M weekly downloads, indicating broad usage across JavaScript communities. |
| Community Support | Growing community with React-centric discussions. | ✓Large community with extensive resources and third-party support. |
| Bundle Size (gzip) | 29.5 kB when gzipped, manageable for modern applications. | ✓1.4 kB gzipped, very minimal and beneficial for load times. |
| Use Case Suitability | Highly suitable for React-focused applications. | ✓Versatile enough for a wide range of JavaScript apps. |